Featuring Darren Criss
Can I just check whether or notis going to be listed as a featured artist on Season 3 songs. It's probably good if some consistency is held, whether that means removing the FAs from Warbler songs, or continuing to add them to new songs.
- That's a good question. I'm assuming you're talking about the "fa" (vs. the "ft") notations. Before I started sort of maintaining the songs, I recall seeing a few examples where someone had listed any and all (within limits) artists in a song regardless of whether they were regular cast members or guest stars (sssh 18:53, October 21, 2011 (UTC) and ). I kept that up because no one seemed to say anything otherwise. If you have any ideas, I'd certainly be open to any ideas.
- Now I don't actually watch Glee so I cannot give an experts opinion on this, but as far as I am concerned, it either needs to be everyone in a song, or just the guest artists. In the latter case, Criss should not be FAed in the Warbler songs, as he is now considered a series regular. In terms of choosing which method should be used, we should consider how many of the artist have pages which don't just say 'Glee Cast member'. Artists with pages which just say 'Glee Cast member' should not have really pages to start with. I cite as an example of this, where no artists are FAed on the song pages, as only Criss has any valid artist page. Thus, in my opinion, only guests should be FAed.
- Just FYI, I was following a list like this for the FA in each song .
- But anyway, sounds good. To be honest, I don't have a strong opinion either way...and I do acknowledge that the track listing FT and each song FA not matching may be weird and inconsistent. Instead of listing the people in the song, I suppose there could be a better job done in the lyrics of the song noting who's singing the solos. sssh 23:10, October 22, 2011 (UTC)
Jessica Simpson - Do You Know
RUS: Вы вчера забыли поставить обложку последнего альбома Джессики Симпсон "Do You Know". Я её сегодня добавил. Спасибо за понимание. --Bibigon54 04:28, November 1, 2011 (UTC)
ENG: You forgot to put yesterday's latest album cover of Jessica Simpson "Do You Know". I added it today. Thank you for your understanding. --Bibigon54 04:28, November 1, 2011 (UTC)
- Mm, yes, I didn't add it because the album page didn't exist yet. But thanks for adding it! sssh 07:38, November 1, 2011 (UTC)
Rumour Has It
You're saying that the live performance versions and what makes more sense should be the lyrics and not the original version? Because the original version does say "stayed". Jerome (Ian Streeter) Just my contribs! 17:59, June 20, 2012 (UTC)
- No, I was just offering some more examples as to why the original does, in fact, say "strayed". It's not the most clear lyric, true, but I was just giving additional reasons. sssh 06:07, June 22, 2012 (UTC)
When You Believe
Well, the Mariah Carey song "When You Believe" is credited as a single off of Mariah Carey's album, not Whitney Houston's. I had the same sort of problem with xxTimberlakexx. So, this isn't a first time thing. hard4me (talk) 20:53, August 13, 2012 (UTC)with
Old time and bluegrass wiki
- There's no version of this song performed only by   sssh 01:52, April 28, 2013 (UTC) , it's a duet?
- I jumped at seeing a redirect to a red link :)
- But that aside, a duet can be represented by tl|fa in tl|SongHeader, as you know. The idea being avoiding a whole lot of new artist pages for duets.
- X & Y namespace is best reserved for collab albums like King & Clapton, Hooker 'N' Heat. But as long as the duet song pages you are creating end up linked on VA/Soundtrack/musicals, and no new artist pages are created, it's acceptable.--ES (talk) 02:12, April 28, 2013 (UTC)
- Yeah, I understand, sometimes I jump the gun and work backwards a little, heh, will try to be better with that.
- But in general, there are just certain duets that really can't be attributed to one artist or the other, like these two divas sssh 03:27, April 28, 2013 (UTC) . You can't even know how excited I was when tl|SongCollaboration was added!
In case you didn't notice...
Changes Like what?
- If you listen to the song, you'll see there's an added lyric in the middle of the song that is not in the original...it actually appears to be from another song, this makes sense. (just them shouting their names, but still). Not only that, it is a remix. Maybe
- From general practice around the rest of the site, seems fa is reserved for actual contributing vocals or instruments, like sssh 04:10, May 8, 2013 (UTC) , not remixes of existing songs .
- I came across a dupe ES (talk) 09:29, May 9, 2013 (UTC) , so I redirected, and added the fa to the better page, that's all! Whether fa is applicable or not is the next editor's issue. I neither listen to the song nor do I go randomly throwing 2ndry artists into song headers ;) You added verses to that song, not I! --
Featuring/Secondary artists/& or fa or not
- On the issue of fa/and/with/&/vs. etc. (in every language, not just English): it is a way to indicate that there is a notable artist accompanying the primary artist, and it is used interchangabily. At mb I have come across same song and some versions say featuring some say vs. some say & or And. It makes no difference whatsoever whichever is used. For simplicity I use fa, unless the entire album is a collaboration. Examples:
- It's Buddy Guy's album, so Eric Clapton (the guitar god that he has been all his life) goes into fa. and so does everybody else who appeared with BG on each song. BG is the album artist.
- But...when we have an album entirely by two artists , it is a collab album and both are album artists so every song is a CollabSong, no fa, unless a notable third etc. artist is indicated.
- There is no policy (clear or otherwise) about using fa at lw. As new templates came to life, things changed. A very good example from our few real gold songs is : vocals are by , but it is not in fa, it is in the credits section of the song, because back then we didn't have fa, and nobody bothered changing it ever since. So here is one example where the vocalist doesn't sit in the song header or if he/she does, it's only as fa. cheers
Thirty Nine Lashes
So we have two identical lyrics, question is which one to keep, and according to which reference, and what is the proper attribution:
SOTD May 27, 2014
Hi Sssh! I'm just here to tell you that your nomination of has won Song of the Day for May 27, 2014!
Thanks for nominating a song and for contributing to LyricWiki!
-ÜberBot (talk) 06:59, May 27, 2014 (UTC)